Why Star Wars Made a Large Mistake Hiring Patty Jenkins

Why Star Wars Made a Large Mistake Hiring Patty Jenkins
Hollywood in Toto

We’re residing within the age of superlatives, but not sufficient are heaped upon Jon Favreau.

Not solely did the author/director jumpstart the MCU with 2008’s “Iron Man,” he directed the largest Christmas film of the fashionable age, “Elf.” He additionally wrote and co-starred within the seminal display screen bromance “Swingers.”

That was only a warm-up act for his largest popular culture magic trick thus far. Favreau introduced “Star Wars” again from the popular culture grave with “The Mandalorian.”

So who does Staff “Star Wars” assume can revive the franchise’s film fortunes?

Patty Jenkins.

The director will helm “Rogue Squadron,” the primary new “Star Wars” film following the poorly obtained trilogy that capped the Skywalker saga. The following “Star Wars” movie hits theaters Christmas 2023, assuming the theatrical mannequin nonetheless exists by then.

The selection appeared sensible, even hopeful, as lately as a couple of weeks in the past. Now? It’d seal the destiny of “Star Wars” as a theatrical empire.

Sound harsh? Take a protracted, onerous take a look at Jenkins’ new movie, “Marvel Lady 1984.” It brims with all of the sins followers accused the brand new “Star Wars” movies of committing.

  • Woke storytelling
  • Muddied narratives
  • Large plot holes
  • Feminism on steroids
  • Ignoring canon

Sure, Jenkins directed a flat-out gem with 2017’s “Marvel Lady” and deserves loads of credit score for it. It’s why the “Star Wars”-Jenkins pairing appeared so promising.

She’s much more arms on with the sequel, although, given her rising Hollywood clout. She possible felt much less strain from Warner Bros. fits following the runaway success of the primary “Marvel Lady” journey. Plus, she co-wrote the story and screenplay for “WW84,” that means her fingerprints are all around the completed product.

It’s her child, and it’s a large number.

The truth is, as soon as the geek hype for the sequel subsided the movie’s Rotten Tomatoes rating sank from the excessive 80s to a modest 65 p.c “contemporary.”

That’s no accident.

So Disney, the studio that now owns Star Wars, Inc., is entrusting its film franchise to Jenkins.


For starters, Disney is as woke as any movie studio lately. Jenkins would be the first feminine director to helm a “Star Wars” characteristic. That issues.

It’s additionally possible why Lucasfilm President Kathleen Kennedy, the particular person in control of the “Star Wars” model, nonetheless has her job after torching “Star Wars” as a theatrical juggernaut. Every of the primary “Star Wars” sequels created beneath her watch made much less cash than the earlier movie.

Kennedy constructed that.

The opposite “Star Wars” movies beneath Kennedy’s reign delivered combined outcomes.

“Solo: A Star Wars Story” grew to become a field workplace disappointment with a $213 million haul. “Rogue One: A Star Wars Story” served up the very best thrills of the brand new “Star Wars” period, incomes a good $532 million regardless of its microscopic ties to the Skywalker clan.

The identical “Star Wars” followers who clamor for Child Yoda merch really feel far much less hooked up to the “new” “Star Wars” characters from the latest trilogy.

Analysts can level to many causes for “Star Wars”” artistic decline, from by no means assembling the unique trilogy’s core heroes on display screen to a story that felt scribbled down on the fly.

The movie’s woke nods clearly factored into the equation. Suppose Mary Sue heroines (Rey, Rose Tico) strained progressive subplots (“The Final Jedi’s” on line casino debacle) and emasculating the one character who may carry Han Solo’s rogue torch (Oscar Isaac’s Poe Dameron).

Any probability Jenkins, given the keys to the largest house franchise in historical past, received’t repeat what she delivered to “WW84?”

  • An anti-GOP villain
  • Bald feminism
  • Overt victimhood for its feminine characters

Slim, meet none.

Motion pictures like “Marvel Lady 1984” and the upcoming “Star Wars: Rogue Squadron” should thrive exterior the American market to make fiscal sense. China is presently the dominant theatrical marketplace for Hollywood given the present pandemic — and it might stay so transferring ahead.

So how did “Marvel Lady 1984” fare in China? The film under-performed in its opening weekend to the tune of $18.eight million, getting bested by a Chinese language unique (“The Rescue”). “WW84” plummeted 92 p.c the next weekend.

That’s not a typo.

The far-left Hollywood Reporter added some essential context to “WW84’s” awful exhibiting.

The sequel’s slide is especially disappointing since China, which has bounced again strongly from the novel coronavirus pandemic and is thought for its affinity for superhero motion pictures, was anticipated to be the title’s largest theatrical market.

That is the director “Star Wars” is pinning its cinematic rebirth round?

Favreau made us care about “Star Wars” once more with a easy, foolproof formulation. Skip the woke theatrics. Inform a narrative hearkening again to core parts like a stoic important character, companionship and selfless acts of heroism. Ship slam-bang motion with out hand-wringing.

Briefly, summon the artistic spirit George Lucas first unleashed on the tradition in 1977. Can Jenkins do the identical with “Rogue Squadron?” The proof up to now suggests she will’t and Kennedy doesn’t care.

Initially Printed by – Christian Toto

Unique Supply –

What do you think?


Written by Harry Rosen

Harry Rosen is an accomplished explorer, photographer, creative director, speaker, and author.

‘Spouse Swap’ Son Allegedly Tried To Escape From Psychological Hospital Twice

‘Spouse Swap’ Son Allegedly Tried To Escape From Psychological Hospital Twice

Promising Younger Lady – A story about violence in opposition to girls

Promising Younger Lady – A story about violence in opposition to girls